polis: a collective blog about cities worldwide
places

Return to Jackson Heights

by Melanie Friedrichs

From Providence

Every few months, the gravity of New York City sucks me in and pounds my feet madly to the pavement until I escape, exhausted, on an outbound bus. Last Saturday, it pulled me to a place I had visited only once before. It was an assignment for "Cities in the 21st Century," a comparative study-abroad program that whisks American students around the world to experience urban forms in other countries, beginning with two weeks at home. The assignment was simple: Go to Jackson Heights. Riding the subway to Queens last weekend brought back my impressions and discoveries from that day.

Richardson Apartments: A Fresh Take on Affordable Housing

by Min Li Chan

Nested within San Francisco's affluent Hayes Valley neighborhood, Richardson Apartments is an unconventional affordable housing initiative for the recently homeless. Riding the bus home last weekend, I caught a glimpse of the building's impressive facade a few intersections away, hopped off the bus and ventured closer to take a look.

Quiet Moments in a Manhattan Subway Station

by Katia Savchuk

During the rush-hour crush, New York's subway stations are as lonely as they are crowded. I recently caught some quiet moments in the tide of humanity at the 42nd Street station in Manhattan ...

A German Coal Pit, Reinvented

by Cristiana Strava and Stefan Esselborn


Miners' homes at Robert Müser mine in Bochum, 1961. Source: Bundesarchiv

"Deep in the West, where the sun is gathering dust," bellows Herbert Grönemeyer in an ode to his home town, Bochum, "things are better, much better than you think." Even for the bestselling German pop artist of all time, this was a tough sell. Bochum is located in the middle of the Ruhr region, colloquially known as "der Pott," or "the coal pit." Generations of Germans have grown up to think of it as a place filled with coal dust and poisonous fumes, smokestacks and gritty miners’ towns and the roar and glow of blast furnaces. Like many boom regions of the classic industrial period, from the Yorkshire coal fields to the U.S. Rust Belt, the Ruhr has been hit hard by the decline of mining and heavy industry since the 1960s. The jobs vanished; rusting steel, crumbling bricks and a heavily polluted landscape remained. How to build a new identity from the industrial ruins of yesteryear in the postindustrial age is a question few have answered convincingly.

No place embodies the Ruhr’s faded industrial glory and recent woes more than the Zollverein mining compound in the city of Essen. The iconic "Doppelbock" winding tower of Zollverein’s central Shaft XII, also known as the "Eiffel Tower of the Ruhr," has served as a symbol of the region since its completion in 1932.


The Eiffel Tower of the Ruhr. Source: Wikipedia


Zollverein as fridge magnet. Source: Zollverein-Shop

The complex was known as Europe’s biggest and most modern coal mine. In its heyday, the tower hauled 12,000 tons of soft coal from the depths of the earth each day. An intricate system of conveyor belts transported the coal to Europe’s largest coke ovens, where it was immediately processed to fuel the furnaces of the region’s booming steel industry. Up to 8,000 workers earned their living in the dust, heat, noise and fumes of the Zollverein complex. At day’s end they went home to their company-built houses and shopped at the company stores.


Shaft VII surface buildings, with characteristic red brick walls and steel trelliswork. The smokestack on the boiler house in the center was taken down in 1981. Source: Stefan Esselborn

Aside from record output, Zollverein was also an architectural landmark. The young architects Fritz Schupp and Martin Kremmer, who started planning the shaft in 1927, were strongly influenced by the Bauhaus movement and its "form follows function" style. With the stark symmetry and minimalist geometry of its surface buildings, lined up along two intersecting axes, Zollverein's Shaft XII soon earned a reputation as the "world’s most beautiful coal mine." The innovative use of red brick on a steel skeleton construction set the style for a generation of industrial architecture across the region.


The winding tower, focal point of the production axis. Source: Stefan Esselborn

When Zollverein closed in 1986, it was the last remaining active mine in Essen. Instead of letting the complex tumble down, the state of North Rhine-Westphalia bought the site and preserved it as a memorial. After a substantial renovation, Zollverein opened to visitors in 1999. Declared a UNESCO World Heritage Site in 2001, it is now a main stop on the German and European Route of Industrial Heritage. Tourists follow the overhead conveyor belts through what is now a dense young forest, or take a walk on the former train tracks, converted into pathways. Visitors can take one of numerous guided tours, or learn about the history of coal and steel in the former coal-washing plant, revamped and equipped with a bright orange escalator by Rem Koolhaas’s OMA. The former shower facilities house a Performing Arts and Choreographic Centre (PACT). Numerous concerts, art exhibitions and performances are scheduled in and around the old industrial structures throughout the year.


The former coal-washing Plant, where the coal was separated from stone and other unwanted materials, now houses the Ruhr Museum. Source: OMA


Tents for a festival are being set up under one of the many overpasses. Source: Stefan Esselborn

The gigantic coking plant, built between 1957 and 1961, has undergone some of the most spectacular transformations. A Ferris wheel was carved into the ovens where coal was baked into coke at 1250°C until 1993. In summer, visitors can take a dip in an outdoor pool, surrounded by a colorful if slightly rusty maze of pipes and stairways. In winter, an ice skating rink allows you to glide past the steel doors of its 304 ovens.


Coking plant with Werksschwimmbad pool and Ferris wheel. Source: Stefan Esselborn


The central alley in front of the ovens (steel doors on the right) becomes an ice rink in winter. Source: Stefan Esselborn

True to the site’s architectural heritage, design has been a special focus at Zollverein. The old boiler house now accommodates the red dot design museum, displaying products that have won the design award of the same name. In 2006 the Zollverein School of Management and Design opened in a futuristic cube building designed by the Japanese architects SANAA. Together with the ambitiously named "designstadt N°1," which offers office space for creatives, it was supposed to form the core of a new "design city" in what is still the region's poorest area. So far, the substantial public investments do not seem to have payed off. The school had to close in 2008 for lack of students, while the designstadt is mostly empty.


Zollverein School of Management and Design. Source: Wikipedia

Nevertheless, Zollverein has once more become a pace-setter. It is today the prestigious centerpiece of a whole region’s effort to rebrand itself as the "Metropole Ruhr," a 21st-century metropolis open to high tech and high culture, an international tourist destination and postindustrial economic powerhouse. The region is trying to make the best of the fact that the air has once again become breathable, and even bathing in the rivers is no longer a danger to one’s life and health. Landscape and adventure parks, museums, exhibitions and cultural venues are springing up left and right. Few of the giant waste rock piles, so characteristic for the area, are without an art installation or walkable landmark. In recognition of these efforts, Essen was named the European Capital of Culture in 2010.


Abandoned switchboard at the Zollverein coking plant. Source: Stefan Esselborn

This does not mean that the region’s troubles are over. As economic readjustment progresses, new social tensions are arising. Costly rededication projects have added to the already frighteningly high debt burden of local municipalities, many of which are worse off than equivalents in the formerly communist German East. Tourism and culture cannot themselves replace hundreds of thousands of lost industrial jobs. Whether it will be possible to attract viable businesses in sufficient numbers remains to be seen. However, to witness creative and historically sensitive reworking of an industrial past, the Ruhr region is most certainly worth a visit. Things are better than you might think.

Additional information:

Wellterbe Zollverein (official website, in German)
Zollverein Coal Mine Industrial Complex in Essen (UNESCO profile)
Zollverein Industrial Complex (landscape study by Jennifer Chandler)
OMA Masterplan for the Zollverein Mining Complex (Arcspace review)


Rock climbing in a former coke bunker at Landschaftspark Duisburg-Nord. Source: Landschaftspark


"Pulse Park" light installation in Bochum’s Westpark. Source: Stefan Esselborn

Stefan Esselborn is a doctoral student with a focus on colonial Africa. In his free time he loves to explore postindustrial landscapes.

This is part of a collection of featured places from around the world. If you’d like to share photos of a place you find interesting, please add them to the Flickr group or send them to info@thepolisblog.org and we’ll publish your feature. Video and sound recordings are also welcome.

+ share

Boldest of Pastel Architecture

by Peter Sigrist

In 2007, the "Grand Park" residential complex was completed along the border of the now-defunct Frunze Central Aerodrome in Moscow. Located on Khodynka Field, within 5 miles of the city center, Frunze was the city's only airport until 1941.

National Park Commemorates Women’s Rights

by Peter Sigrist

Recent visits to the George Eastman House and the Susan B. Anthony House left me troubled. The museums were far from disappointing, but their budgets seemed widely unequal. As one might expect, the founder of Eastman Kodak lived in a stunning mansion in a neighborhood of mansions, and his estate is now a destination for photography enthusiasts around the world.

Ownership and Identity in Kennedy Plaza

by Melanie Friedrichs



Ask anyone where the center of Providence is and they’ll point you to Kennedy Plaza. Geographically it is a natural center, located in a river valley between two hills. College Hill (to the east) is home to Brown University, and Federal Hill (to the west) is the heart of Providence's Italian-American community. Kennedy Plaza's layout follows the traditional colonial pattern, with the Providence City Hall facing the U.S. District Court. (According to local legend, when mayor Buddy Cianci was on trial he would walk across Kennedy Plaza to make his court dates.) The plaza is also a transportation hub, first as the home of a train station from 1847 to 1980, and now as a bus depot.


Components of Kennedy Plaza. Source: Greater Kennedy Plaza

Kennedy Plaza’s assets don’t necessarily add up to its status as city center. The State Capital and the Providence County Courthouse are located elsewhere. The first central plaza in Providence, Market Square, is located across the river. The bus depot is ugly and loud and takes up half the plaza’s usable space. But while other spaces can claim equal proximity to public buildings, greater historical importance and aesthetic advantages, they stand empty while Kennedy Plaza bustles with loiterers, tourists, commuters and professionals.


Market Place, the former center of ownership and identity in Providence. Source: City of Providence

Kennedy Plaza stands out because it has become a symbol of identity and (contested) ownership for the people of Providence. It is a reminder of what Setha Low, director of the Public Space Research Group at the City University of New York and author of "On the Plaza: The Politics of Public Space and Culture" describes as the “phenomenological and symbolic experience of a space as mediated by social processes such as exchange, conflict, and control.” The making of Kennedy Plaza is not a story one can Google and, as a relative newcomer to Providence, I am not in the best position to tell it. According to William McKenzie Wormwood, a historian at the Rhode Island Historical Preservation & Heritage Commission, Kennedy Plaza “is the city's most constantly reworked space, and fully interpreting its history would fill a book that could be a landmark in understanding American urbanism.” That said, I can guess at several key historical processes behind the plaza's current centrality.


Providence City Hall.

First was the construction of City Hall in 1878. While arguably not the most important political building in Providence, City Hall is the most approachable. The modest facade is removed from the sidewalk by only a few steps, welcoming democratic participation in contrast to the state capitol’s grand walkway and imposing dome. City Hall, not the State House, is the primary voice in government for the average Providence citizen.


Joaquim DeBarros waits in front of the Kennedy Plaza transportation center. Photo by Bill Murphy. Source: Belo Blog

Second is the bus depot, redesigned and formalized by the Rhode Island Public Transit Authority in the late 1990s. To the probable chagrin of the plaza’s more well-to-do tenants, the bus depot attracts the homeless and unemployed by providing benches and a constant stream of pedestrian traffic. Kennedy Plaza provides rare visibility for the dispossessed, who in other cities are often vetted away from the central public space.


Snow falls on Occupy Providence. Source: Occupy Providence

Third is local politics. The status of Kennedy Plaza as a space of contested ownership became most obvious when Occupy Providence moved into Burnside Park in October 2011. And, in fact, many of the participants had been occupying Kennedy Plaza for years through frequent demonstrations, petitions and orations in front of City Hall or the Court House.


Festival Ballet Providence performs in Kennedy Plaza. Source: Greater Kennedy Plaza

Recently the Greater Kennedy Plaza coalition has been working to reinvent the plaza once again, part of an initiative to “transform Downtown Providence into a lively public square, rich with activity.” The coalition includes several foundations, more than five state and local government bodies and Bank of America, among others. I see their project as another bid for ownership of this contested space.

This is part of a collection of featured places from around the world. If you’d like to share photos of a place you find interesting, please add them to the Flickr group or send them to info@thepolisblog.org and we’ll publish your feature. Video and sound recordings are also welcome.

Credits: Photos of Kennedy Plaza by Melanie Friedrichs unless otherwise noted in the captions.


+ share

A Brooklyn Sanctuary

by Rebecka Gordan


Source: Green-Wood Historic Fund

In the boisterous metropolis, spaces for stillness and reflection are highly sought-after gems. In nineteenth-century New York, one particular cemetery became the number-one public place for gathering and rest.



In fact, just two decades after it was founded in 1838 as one of America’s first rural cemeteries, the Green-Wood Cemetery was attracting half a million visitors a year, rivaling Niagara Falls as the country’s greatest tourist attraction.





Green-Wood became a fashionable place to be buried, and a popular destination for family outings, carriage rides and sculpture viewing. This popularity helped inspire the creation of public parks, including New York City’s Central and Prospect Parks.



The cemetery was the idea of Henry Evelyn Pierrepont, a Brooklyn social leader. Its original landscape architect, David Bates Douglass, found inspiration in Père Lachaise in Paris, as well as Mount Auburn in Cambridge, Massachusetts. Mount Auburn also offers a park-like landscape in the English tradition.



In accordance with landscape fashion at the time, Green-Wood kept the varied topography provided by glacial moraines. Battle Hill, the highest point in Brooklyn, is located here, rising approximately 200 feet above sea level.



Green-Wood contains 478 acres of hills, valleys, glacial ponds and paths that weave through one of the largest outdoor collections of 19th- and 20th-century statuary and mausoleums in the world. Visitors enter through a spectacular gate designed in 1861 by Richard Upjohn in Gothic Revival style. Inside one can find approximately 600,000 graves, including those of Leonard Bernstein, Louis Comfort Tiffany and Jean-Michel Basquiat.





Green-Wood is a designated National Historic Landmark as well as a Revolutionary War historic site, where the Battle of Long Island took place in 1776. It also contains a Civil War Monument, part of an initiative dedicated to identifying and commemorating Civil War veterans.



The Green-Wood Historic Fund organizes informative trolley and walking tours on a regular basis. But for those who don’t mind getting lost in its maze of avenues and narrow paths, Green-Wood is a magnificent place to ramble, rest and ponder in solitude or with a dear one.

This is part of a collection of featured places from around the world. If you’d like to share photos of a place you find interesting, please add them to the Flickr group or send them to info@thepolisblog.org and we’ll publish your feature. Video and sound recordings are also welcome.

Credits: Photos by Rebecka Gordan.

+ share

Cultural Heritage at Risk

by Peter Sigrist


Source: Ogino Knauss

Elena Ovsyannikova of MosKonstruct shares a fascinating and very troubling story about the only building designed by El Lissitzky in Moscow, and its surrounding community. The building was constructed in 1930 to house printing facilities for the Ogoniok Journal. Although it wasn't completed exactly as envisioned (and the design was partially adapted by M. O. Barshch, best known for his work on the Moscow Planetarium), it is a world-renowned masterpiece of Constructivist architecture.


Source: MosKonstruct


Source: MosKonstruct

Beside the print shop, a building (pictured below) designed by Barshch and G. A. Zundblat was added in 1935 to house members of the Zhurgaz journalists' association. According to Ovsyannikova, the Zhurgaz house was visited or inhabited by many famous cultural figures, including Sergei Eisenstein and Mikhail Bulgakov. It is a striking example of the transition between Constructivism and the eclectic neoclassicism of the Stalin years. Current residents have maintained the building exceptionally well.


Source: MosKonstruct


Source: MosKonstruct


Source: MosKonstruct


Source: MosKonstruct

The troubling part is so familiar that it almost seems a caricature of post-Soviet development in Moscow — right down to the role of INTECO, an infamous construction firm owned by the wife of former-mayor Yury Luzhkov.


Source: MosKonstruct

As Ovsyannikova explains in December 2010:
[O]n July 26, 2007, at the request of the Russian Avant-Garde fund, both buildings were entered into the Directory of Cultural Heritage of Moscow and on August 21, 2008 passed committee examination and were recognized as cultural heritage landmarks of the city of Moscow. However, soon afterward the printing house was set on fire and to this day stands without a roof. According to information obtained by a group of tenants from the Prefecture of the Central Administrative District, this territory will be the location for construction of a multi-story residential building with an underground garage for 120 parking places.

The situation with the Zhurgaz house is no less dire. Under the appearances of a charitable action by the government of Moscow for the benefit of the Filmmakers' Union, at a distance of several meters from the house, JSC INTECO is building a new multi-story residential building, which has occupied the entire territory of the yard of the Zhurgaz house. This is despite the ban on "pinpoint construction" announced by Moscow's mayor, despite the categorical disagreement of the tenants, and without coordination with Moskomnasledie (Committee for the Cultural Heritage of the City of Moscow).


Rollover the 2003 photo above to view new construction behind the Zhurgaz house (center) and fire damage to the roof of the former Ogoniok print shop (right) as of 2010. Source: Google Earth


Source: Ogino Knauss

Cases linking Luzhkov with development schemes that encroached upon the living space and cultural heritage of Moscow residents are so prevalent that one has to wonder if the destruction of 5-story buildings during the 2000s had more to do with construction and real estate profits than upgrading housing stock.

See Re:centering Periphery | Ogino Knauss for more recent information and photos, as well as ways to help protect the site.

This is part of a collection of featured places from around the world. If you’d like to share photos of a place you find interesting, please add them to the Flickr group or send them to info@thepolisblog.org and we’ll publish your feature. Video and sound recordings are also welcome.

+ share

Visiting Castle Island in South Boston

by Alexa Mills


Source: Darcnessity

People who say they hate Boston probably haven't been to Castle Island. Getting there is hard: You can either drive, bike, take the Red Line to JFK/UMass and walk for 45 minutes, or live in Southie. But here are 10 reasons why it's worth going:

1) You can watch planes land.





2) You can hear conversations in at least three different languages on a summer day.

3) You can wait for a fish.



4) You can eat french fries and ice cream at Sullivan's.


Source: Sullivan's

5) You can walk, run or rollerblade the Pleasure Bay Loop.

Castle Island
Source: Mass.gov

6) You can take a tour of Fort Independence, a pentagonal granite fort built in 1851.


Source: Boston Public Library


Source: Boston Cityside Realty

7) You can work on your tan.


Source: Lovely Bicycle!

8) You can go swimming at M Street Beach.

9) You can windsurf.


Warning: Disable sound to avoid loud gusts of wind.

10) You can host a party at one of the barbecue pits.

Alexa Mills is editor and media specialist for the Community Innovators Lab (CoLab) at the MIT Department of Urban Studies and Planning. She produces the blog CoLab Radio.

This is part of a collection of featured places from around the world. If you’d like to share photos of a place you find interesting, please add them to the Flickr group or send them to info@thepolisblog.org and we’ll publish your feature. Video and sound recordings are also welcome.

+ share

Havana’s Anti-Imperialist Plaza

by Melissa García Lamarca


Source: Melissa García Lamarca

During my visit to Havana a month ago, several taxi drivers eagerly pointed out the “Tribuna Anti-Imperialista” (Anti-Imperialist Platform, also known as Plaza). Such keenness, added to the space’s intriguing name and design, made a closer visit irresistible.


Source: Melissa García Lamarca

One of the most eye-catching elements on the site is a life-sized statue of the Cuban icon José Martí, clutching a child in one protective arm while pointing vehemently in the opposite direction. The child represents Elián González, the sole survivor of a boat of Cuban refugees that capsized on its way to Miami in 1999, who was the center of a dramatic conflict between the two countries. Martí’s finger is pointed accusingly at the U.S. Interests Section Office located at the end of a linear plaza capped in several places by metal arches.


Source: Geneva Guerin

Built in 1952, the U.S. Interests Section Office was originally the U.S. embassy. The area in front, as pictured below, was known as Dignity Plaza. After Fidel Castro overthrew Fulgencio Batista in the 1959 revolution, the building was used by the Swiss embassy, which represented U.S. interests in Cuba until the U.S. opened its own office in the 1970s. The statue of José Martí and Elián, as well as the metal structures, were erected hastily in 2000 while U.S. courts were reviewing Elián’s case. At the time, the area became a site for daily protests organized by the Cuban government.


The U.S. embassy in the 1950s, with Dignity Plaza in front. Source: ETH Studio Basel


Anti-Imperalist Plaza in 2006. Source: ETH Studio Basel

The plaza’s most recent transformation took place in 2006, when the Cuban government built a mount of flags (el monte de las banderas) with 138 flagpoles. I was told this was done to block the Interest Section’s view of the city, although other sources say it was to obstruct an electronic display board on the side of the U.S. Interest Section Office that displayed messages about Cuba’s social situation and human rights.

A February 2006 inscription at the base of the flags tells yet another story:
This mount of flags serves as a response from the people of Cuba to the clumsy arrogance of the U.S. government: 138 Cuban flags will wave with dignity in front of the eyes of the empire, to remind it, starting today, of every year that the Cuban people have struggled, since our founding fathers gave the cry for independence in 1868. Like then, before the bright shadow of this great mount of flags, we continue fighting as free men and women.

Source: Juventud Rebelde

Today, the site is used largely for rallies and protests against the U.S. The flagpoles sometimes carry black flags adorned with a single white star to represent those fallen in Cuba's fight against terrorism. As I was wandering around, I noticed a group of kids who had appropriated part of the plaza to play a pick-up game of soccer, giving the space a more lived in feel. Concerts sometimes take place as well —Audioslave was the first U.S. rock band to perform an open air concert in Cuba, attracting 50,000 people to a free concert in 2005. As the country is poised on the brink of massive change, with a new regime likely to emerge in the not-too-distant future, time will tell how use of this space evolves.

This is part of a collection of featured places from around the world. If you’d like to share photos of a place you find interesting, please add them to the Flickr group or send them to info@thepolisblog.org and we’ll publish your feature. Video and sound recordings are also welcome.

+ share